| Platinum | Papa's Pizza |
| Gold | Mellow Mushroom Roanoke |
| Silver | Frank's Pizza & Italian Subs |
| Bronze | Greco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bellacino's Pizza & Grinders |
| Top Pick | Benny Marconi |
| Top Pick | Grace's Place Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Gusto's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Highlander Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sal's Italian Resturant |