| Platinum | Pancho Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Los Arcos |
| Silver | Tacos Coronado |
| Bronze | El Rodeo |
| Top Pick | Agave Azul Mexican Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | Alejandro's Mexican Grill - Downtown |
| Top Pick | Camino Viejo Grill & Bar |
| Top Pick | Diablos Tacos |
| Top Pick | Mi Tapatia |
| Top Pick | Pueblo Chico Mexican Grill |