| Platinum | Tim & Zach Thrifty Finds |
| Gold | A Little Bit Hippy |
| Silver | The Bird Cage Boutique |
| Bronze | Marshalls |
| Top Pick | Anyday Outfitters |
| Top Pick | Hamrick's of Roanoke, VA |
| Top Pick | New'D |
| Top Pick | Rooted Boutique & Salon |
| Top Pick | Uptown Cheapskate |
| Top Pick | Vintage Vault |