| Platinum | Tim & Zach Thrifty Finds |
| Gold | ReStore- Habitat for Humanity in the Roanoke Valley |
| Silver | Bargain Barn |
| Bronze | Goodwill Stores |
| Top Pick | 2nd Helpings Shop |
| Top Pick | New Fangled Bride & Formals |
| Top Pick | New'D |
| Top Pick | Rescue Mission |
| Top Pick | Rodeo Thrift |
| Top Pick | Salvation Army |