| Platinum | Macado's |
| Gold | Joe's Deli |
| Silver | R.T. Smith's Deli |
| Bronze | Brambleton Deli |
| Top Pick | Chicken Salad Chick |
| Top Pick | Hangrcy |
| Top Pick | HoneyBaked Ham |
| Top Pick | Montano's International |
| Top Pick | New Yorker Deli & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pete's Deli & Cafe |