| Platinum | Petals & Sugar |
| Gold | Dessert Bar |
| Silver | Get Baked Inc |
| Bronze | Blue Cow Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | bubblecake |
| Top Pick | Montano's International |
| Top Pick | Niy Ells Honeycomb Hideout |
| Top Pick | On The Rise Grandin |
| Top Pick | Rookie's Roanoke |