| Platinum | Papa's Pizza |
| Gold | Mellow Mushroom Roanoke |
| Silver | New York Pizza |
| Bronze | Frank's Pizza & Subs |
| Top Pick | Big Belly Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bobby's Hot & Cheesey |
| Top Pick | Eatza Pizza |
| Top Pick | Food Fanatics Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Frank's at Brambleton |
| Top Pick | Grace's Place Pizzeria |