| Platinum | Blue Cow Ice Cream |
| Gold | Chris's Coffee & Custard |
| Silver | Homestead Creamery |
| Bronze | Salem Ice Cream Parlor |
| Top Pick | Ben & Jerry's |
| Top Pick | Bruster's Real Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Lickity Split |
| Top Pick | Pop's Ice Cream & Soda Bar |
| Top Pick | Sugar Magnolia |